Sunday, March 16, 2008

The Deterioration of the News Media

I have watched with deepening sadness the media's fixation with Rev. Dr. Jeremiah Wright and his sermons. For years I have listened to the Republican Party rail at the bias of the news media. I have heard conservative talk show hosts and politicians talk about the unfair treatment conservative public figures receive at the hands of the liberal, left-wing media. This belief has spawned a whole new news network (Fox) and created media stars out of Bill O'Reilly and Shaun Hannity. I have watched Fox News primarily because I was concerned that the news was not being shown "fair and balanced" on other news outlets. In my mind, they were the corrective for a liberal bias. The news media was out of control. I believe that was a correct concern then - and I believe it is a correct concern now. The story of Jeremiah Wright is a prime example.
I have met Jeremiah Wright (last winter in Minneapolis at the Academy of Homiletics Meeting where he was the Keynote speaker for the Academy). I have heard him preach numerous times on tape, where he is used in many seminaries as a prime example of the black preaching tradition. He is without question a dynamic and powerful speaker (you can hear that even in the clips and snippets that are being aired on the news networks). And, I disagree with much of his theology. Wright is an unabashed liberal in an extremely liberal Protestant denomination (UCC - the United Church of Christ). When he spoke at the Academy, he spoke about and to the liberal members of the gathering. He preaches a strong social gospel message and is a vocal proponent of Black Liberation Theology. I have embraced neither. However, to say that he is out of step with Christianity or that he is saying things that are so offensive that Barrack Obama should distance himself from him and that his judgment as a Presidential candidate is up for grabs is nonsense. What it does confirm is that Obama is a black liberal. Is that news? What it does confirm is that black preachers and black churches still believe that America is a racially prejudiced society and that the only way blacks will ever attain full citizenship and the equality that has been promised but not delivered by the government or the society is if blacks speak out against injustice. Is that news? Wright has said some very stupid things, charging the government for creating HIV as a plague against blacks, for instance. Of course, the government did inject blacks with VD during WWII at Tuskegee and denied it for years. So, as foolish as it sounds, there is precedent for believing it. Do I believe it? No, I think it's stupid. Do I think Wright is an idiot for making the claim. Hmmm. Not in the light of Tuskegee. Is it news to anyone that a black leader thinks that the white establishment would do horrible things to blacks? Wright has lived through the terrible days of the 50's and 60's where lynchings were common and nobody in the community did anything to stop it. If you grew up in that culture and prejudice, you could believe just about anything from those in power against those oppressed.
If Wright had said these things as a stump speech for Obama the media should be all over it. But as a 15 second sound bite from a sermon preached years ago? Is that "fair and balanced"? The media views these kinds of black ethnocentric preaching statements as being out of touch with reality. The reality is that this kind of sermonic activity is done in black pulpits all over the country in both liberal and conservative pulpits. Are they all this extreme? Probably not. Are those sermons filled with similar sentiments? Absolutely. Why? Because the white church pulpits are silent about these issues most of the time. We have left black churches to educate white churches and left them to get themselves out of a social mess that whites created. That's sad. And the weakness of the church today is in no small sense related to the ongoing issue of eleven o'clock still being the most segregated hour in American society. That was sad in the 50's and it is sadder today in the 21st Century.
So, in order to be "fair and balanced" here is what Fox linked their front page story on Wright to today. It is the statement of Trinity Church defending their retiring pastor. It is something you should read.

Chicago, Ill. (March 15, 2008) - “Dr. Wright has preached 207,792 minutes on Sunday for the past 36 years at Trinity United Church of Christ. This does not include weekday worship services, revivals and preaching engagements across America and around the globe, to ecumenical and interfaith communities. It is an indictment on Dr. Wright’s ministerial legacy to present his global ministry within a 15- or 30-second sound bite,” said the Reverend Otis Moss III, pastor of Trinity United Church of Christ.
During the 36-year pastorate of Dr. Wright, Trinity United Church of Christ has grown from 87 to 8,000 members. It is the largest congregation in the United Church of Christ (UCC) denomination.
“It saddens me to see news stories reporting such a caricature of a congregation that has been such a blessing to the UCC’s Wider Church mission,” said the Rev. John H. Thomas, UCC general minister and president, in a released statement. “ … It’s time for us to say ‘No’ to these attacks and declare that we will not allow anyone to undermine or destroy the ministries of any of our congregations in order to serve their own narrow political or ideological ends.”
Trinity United Church of Christ’s ministry is inclusive and global. The following ministries have been developed under Dr. Wright’s ministerial tutelage for social justice: assisted living facilities for senior citizens, day care for children, pastoral care and counseling, health care, ministries for persons living with HIV/AIDS, hospice training, prison ministry, scholarships for thousands of students to attend historically black colleges, youth ministries, tutorial and computer programs, a church library, domestic violence programs and scholarships and fellowships for women and men attending seminary.
Moss added, “The African American Church was born out of the crucible of slavery and the legacy of prophetic African American preachers since slavery has been and continues to heal broken marginalized victims of social and economic injustices. This is an attack on the legacy of the African American Church which led and continues to lead the fight for human rights in America and around the world.”
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. preached the Christian tenet, “love thy neighbor as thyself.” Before Dr. King was murdered on April 4, 1968, he preached, “The 11 o’clock hour is the most segregated hour in America.” Forty years later, the African American Church community continues to face bomb threats, death threats, and their ministers’ characters are assassinated because they teach and preach prophetic social concerns for social justice. Sunday is still the most segregated hour in America."

3 comments:

John said...

First, blacks were not injected with VD at Tuskeegee. Certain men were NOT treated while others were. There is a significant difference.

Second, Fox News is 46 on the scale of the political conservatism of 0-100, with 0 being most conservative and 100 being most liberal. Former Senator Rick Santorum was a 38. Tom Brokaw was a 66. So Fox is actually around the middle.

Jeremiah Wright's sound bites were not the only offensive things he said. My wife and mother-in-law confronted him here in Philly. He has no clue about salvation and the truths of Christ. There is no defense for black liberation theology - it is flawed to the core and most counter-productive. If racism IS the issue, and it is indeed a biggie, it cannot be conquered by demagogery or by those with severe racial issues of their own. Rather, it is conquered by Spirit-filled men such as the deacon Stephen in the book of Acts who solved the partiality problem in the early church. I have personally witnessed wild and irresponsible sermons against the president and all manner of things, and it is neither Biblical nor helpful. Rants on the left or the right are not productive. Genuine love, dialogue, and cleansing by the Holy Spirit are.

PJ said...

John,

Thanks for the correction on Tuskeegee. Since writing this blog entry I have learned that, as you have said, treatment was withheld. My guess is that the difference is more significant to those of us who look back on it than those who experienced it when it could have been prevented. A control group in human experiments is a tried and true principle. It seems rather cruel in this case. And racist.
Again, I do not disagree with your assessment of Wright's theological stance. I am no fan of his extremism. However, I would urge all of us to find ways to dialogue on issues rather than reject them outright. Your willingness to write your thoughts (and I hope mine) are part of the solution, too.
I guess I don't fully understand your comment about Stephen. I'm not sure that Stephen solved the "partiality" problem (I'm not sure how you are defining it) but I do know his stand against Jewish prejudice created a backlash against the Christians that forced many of them to abandon Jerusalem. That is the risk anyone takes in speaking out for God. Let's keep the dialogue up.

John said...

There was problem in treating widows because of ethnicity. I believe the apostles missed an opportunity by being dismissive about "waiting on tables" when after all, Jesus washed their feet. Stephen and the six others had no compunctions about it. No more was mentioned about the problem, which is why they "solved it". They also were instrumental in spreading the word - Stephen to the point he was stoned and received a standing ovation from Jesus Christ, and Philip who was used in Samaria which brought the church out of its provincialism and into the third destination Jesus had commanded them in Acts 1:8.

I love dialogue and in fact head an organization started with a prime goal of increasing ethnic understanding. I teach in the Pakistani community and have a bi-racial family. My business consists of mostly African American clients and we lead a small group in North Philadelphia, a place that we love but which is largely rejected by the white churches. I believe in a totally integrated church, diverse except in dedication to the Lord Jesus Christ which must be the central guiding principle.